Project and process writing models compared

Team writing based on a project model of writing writing shares several features with longstanding process models of writing instruction.

The project model differs, however, in the purpose of each common feature.

Similar Features

Different Purposes

Feature

Process Model

Project Model

Planning

Planning is scheduling.

Planning is replanning.

Standards

Implicit writing standards for college.

Explicit college, departmental, programmatic standards.

Peer Review

Peer review of writing after prolonged drafting.

Peer review of understanding, daily.

Work

Instructor- or supervisor- organized process by serial phase.

Self-organized team process by cross-functional commitments.

Writing

Writing is rewriting of the whole.

Writing is polishing a part.

Performance

Measure individual (and, optionally, team) performance.

Measure individual, team, and agile process performance.

Assessment

Evaluates written product and individual writer.

Evaluates written product, team productivity, individual performance, relationships, and tools of process.

Learning

Writing to learn.

Supporting transparency to learn.

Productivity

Implicitly measured.

Explicitly measured.

 

Process vs Agile Model